Nostalgia Games: Why They Still Slap and What the Industry Is Screwing Up

In partnership with

Yo, Pokgaigamer here. If you’re expecting some sugar-coated, feel-good newsletter, go read the Pokémon Center blog, lah. Here, we talk real — and if you can’t handle the truth, just uninstall and go back to Candy Crush. Let’s get into why all these nostalgia games like Pokémon GO, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and Dragon Ball Z are still printing money, and what the so-called “game designers” and “marketers” should actually learn (but probably won’t). But first a word from our sponsor:

Top investors are buying this “unlisted” stock

When the team that co-founded Zillow and grew it into a $16B real estate leader starts a new company, investors notice. That’s why top firms like SoftBank invested in Pacaso.

Disrupting the real estate industry once again, Pacaso’s streamlined platform offers co-ownership of premier properties – revamping a $1.3T market.

By handing keys to 2,000+ happy homeowners, Pacaso has already made $110m+ in gross profits.

Now, after 41% gross profit growth last year, they recently reserved the Nasdaq ticker PCSO. But the real opportunity is now, at the unlisted stage.

Until May 29, you can join Pacaso as an investor for just $2.80/share.

Invest before the window closes.

_{This is a paid advertisement for Pacaso’s Regulation A offering. Please read the offering circular at invest.pacaso.com. Reserving a ticker symbol is not a guarantee that the company will go public. Listing on the NASDAQ is subject to approvals. Under Regulation A+, a company has the ability to change its share price by up to 20%, without requalifying the offering with the SEC.}

Why Are These Nostalgia Games Still So Damn Successful?

• Nostalgia Is a Drug
  You think people play Pokémon GO because it’s innovative? Please. Half the player base is just reliving their primary school days catching imaginary monsters instead of catching feelings. The Pokémon brand is like cockroach — cannot die one. Even after nearly a decade, people still come back because they want to feel young, not because the game is flawless148.

• Brand Power, Baby
  Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Dragon Ball Z — these names are legendary. You slap Pikachu or Goku on anything, it sells. Doesn’t matter if the gameplay is recycled or the servers lag until your grandma can finish mahjong before you load in. The brand alone brings in whales and free-to-play leeches alike14.

• Gameplay That Actually Works
  Pokémon GO nailed the AR thing. Walk around, catch monsters, pretend you’re exercising. Simple, but it works. They keep adding new features, events, and mechanics like Dynamax and Galar stuff to keep the grind fresh for the hardcore and casuals37. But don’t get it twisted — if the gameplay sucked, nostalgia alone wouldn’t save it.

• Community and FOMO
  The game forces you to go outside, meet people, join raids, and get salty when someone else gets the shiny you wanted. Social pressure and FOMO (fear of missing out) keep people logging in. If you miss an event, too bad, wait another year — or pay up for those special passes17.

What Should Game Designers and Marketers Learn (If They Got Brain)?

• Stop Milking, Start Innovating
  Don’t just throw nostalgia at us and call it a day. If your game is just a lazy cash grab, gamers will uninstall faster than you can say “server maintenance.” Pokémon GO survived because Niantic kept updating, fixing, and adapting — even during COVID, they made remote raids so people could still play from home1.

• Monetization Without Screwing Players
  We know you want our money, but don’t make everything pay-to-win or hide all the good stuff behind a paywall. People are quitting because of this nonsense25. If you want long-term whales, treat your players like humans, not ATMs.

• Listen to Your Community
  Gamers are toxic, yeah, but also honest. If everyone says your event sucks, maybe don’t run it again. Use feedback, fix bugs, and stop pretending you know better than the people actually playing your game15.

• Keep It Social, Keep It Fresh
  Games like Pokémon GO work because they turn real life into a playground. Community events, tournaments, and new content keep people coming back. If your game is just a solo grind, it’s dead on arrival17.

What Do Gamers Really Think?

• “Game is fun, but getting more pay-to-win. Not as accessible as before. If they keep this up, more people will quit.” — Some salty Redditor2.

• “Still playing after 9 years, but Niantic still can’t fix basic bugs. At least the events are fun sometimes.” — Every veteran trainer5.

• “If not for nostalgia, I wouldn’t bother. But I need my childhood fix, so here I am.” — Literally everyone.

TL;DR

Nostalgia is powerful, but it’s not a free pass for lazy design. If you want to make money like Pokémon GO, build a real community, keep the gameplay fun, don’t screw your players, and maybe — just maybe — listen to the people actually playing your game. Otherwise, your game will die faster than a Magikarp in a thunderstorm.

Pokgaigamer out. Don’t @ me unless you got a shiny to trade.